Legislative Testimony Competing Principal Representation State
http://proethica.org/ontology/intermediate#LegislativeTestimonyCompetingPrincipalRepresentationState
Definition
State in which two or more professional engineers testify before a legislative or governmental body on a matter of public policy, each representing a different principal with a stake in the outcome (e.g., a public agency versus a private company), and each advocating for a different technical solution based on their own engineering analysis — where the engineers' affiliations and principals are disclosed, the criticism of competing analyses is grounded in engineering data rather than personal attack, and the legislative body is the ultimate decision-maker. In this state, the engineers' advocacy role is transparent and institutionally sanctioned, distinguishing it from covert or undisclosed partisan engagement, and the mutual technical criticism is ethically permissible provided it remains objective, data-supported, and professionally conducted.
Properties
Source Evidence
TTL
Metadata
bdfd8e196dd98567...