DP1

DecisionPoint
http://proethica.org/ontology/cases#DecisionPoint

DP1

Should Engineer T disclose the complete factual record of post-accident deliberations during the deposition — including the personal belief that a professional error may have been made and the internal exchange with Engineer B — while refraining from volunteering an error characterization that has not been legally or professionally adjudicated?

Engineer T's obligation to disclose the full project history — including the post-accident site visit findings, the internal deliberation with Engineer B about whether an error had occurred, and the basis for the joint 'no error' determination — during deposition, while refraining from voluntarily characterizing the design as an error absent a direct question requiring such characterization.

Disclose the complete factual record of post-accident deliberations — including the personal belief that an error may have been made and the internal exchange with Engineer B — while answering all deposition questions fully and accurately, without volunteering an unsolicited error characterization

Withhold the post-accident internal deliberations and personal error belief from deposition testimony entirely, responding only to the literal scope of questions asked without disclosing the existence of the prior self-assessment or the exchange with Engineer B

Engineer T